Although rectal cancer surgery that preserves the muscle the closes the rectum (anal sphincter-sparing surgery) has doubled in the last sixteen years, more than half of patients in the United States do not receive it. When the anal sphincter is removed, a permanent colostomy is necessary.
Analyzing data from the National Inpatient Sample, a randomized selection of patients treated in United States hospitals, researchers found that 27 percent of rectal cancer patients had sphincter-preserving surgery in 1988. By 2003, the rate had increased to 48 percent. They noted that there has been no significant change in that rate since 1999.
However, they discovered that patients who were older, black, or male had less chance for sphincter-saving surgery. In addition, those whose treatment was covered by medicaid or who lived in low-income zip codes also had lower rates of such surgery.
Concluding, the team wrote,
Despite a significant increase in the rate of sphincter-sparing surgery with reestablishment of intestinal continuity, most radical resections for rectal cancer in hospitals in the United States result in a colostomy. Patients vulnerable to proctectomy without sphincter preservation were older, male, black, used Medicaid insurance, or lived in lower income zip codes.
They also noted,
Worldwide, “centers of excellence” in rectal cancer surgery report high rates of anal sphincter-sparing surgery (70-90 percent) after proctectomy
SOURCE: Ricciardi et al, Diseases of the Colon and Rectum,Volume 50, Number 8, August 2007.
WHAT THIS MEANS FOR PATIENTS
A second surgical opinion is important for people with rectal cancer particularly if they have been told that they will need a permanent colostomy.
Patients can locate a board-certified member of the American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons practicing near them.


