Posted by Kate Murphy on January 24th, 2008
FROM 2008 ORLANDO GI SYMPOSIUM
Patients without insurance are twice as likely to be diagnosed with advanced colon or rectal cancer than those with either Medicare or private insurance. Patients whose treatment is covered by Medicaid have a fifty percent larger risk of having an advanced cancer (stage III or IV).
Being diagnosed at stage III, where cancer has spread to nearby lymph nodes, or stage IV, where cancer is found in distant organs, greatly decreases the chances that the patient will survive.
Researchers with the American Cancer Society studied nearly half a million patients diagnosed with colon or rectal cancer between 1998 and 2004, whose cases were entered in the National Cancer Data Base. The NCDB includes about 75% of all US cancer patients.
The majority of patients (61.0 percent) were 65 or older and covered by Medicare, another 32.4 percent had private insurance. Two percent were uninsured and 2.5 percent were covered by Medicaid. Another 2.2 percent had Medicare, but were younger than 65.
The scientists calculated the odds that patients without insurance, covered by Medicaid, or covered by Medicare would be diagnosed with later stage cancer compared to those with private insurance.
More likely to be diagnosed with stage II rather than stage I disease:
- Uninsured patients: 90 percent more likely or almost twice the risk.
- Medicaid-covered: 40 percent more likely or about half again the risk.
- Medicare: no difference for either those 65 and older or those under 65.
More likely to be diagnosed with stage III or IV versus stage I
- Uninsured patients: 100 percent more likely or twice the risk.
- Medicaid patients: fifty percent more likely
- Medicare: no significant difference
The research team also found other factors that were associated with advanced stage at diagnosis including:
- Black or Hispanic race
- Females
- Older age
- Treatment in non-teaching hospitals or hospitals that did not do research
- Residence in zip codes with lower incomes and lower educational levels
Michael T. Halpern, MD, PhD, and his colleagues at Health Services Research at the American Cancer Society in Atlanta concluded,
Uninsured and Medicaid patients with colorectal cancer have increased likelihoods of more advanced disease at diagnosis compared to patients with private insurance. Improved screening and access to other medical care among these underserved populations may reduce this substantial disparity.
SOURCE: Halpern et al, Association between insurance status and stage at diagnosis for patients with colorectal cancer, 2008 Gastrointestinal Cancers Symposium, abstract number 275.